When former masked superhero the Comedian is murdered, vigilante Rorschach looks into it and begins to unravel a sinister plot. Set in an alternate 1985 the world is on the brink of disaster as the US and Russia flex their nuclear muscles. Masked vigilantes have been outlawed by the government and things look rather bleak. Most of the former superheroes have retired, but eventually they come to realize that they are still needed to watch over mankind, but as the tag line states, “Who watches the Watchmen?”
I will start by sayig that yes, I am a big fan of the original comic. I will also mention that I purposely did not go back and read the comic again whe I heard this film was being made. I wanted my mind to be as fresh as possible, I didn’t want to spend the entire film comparing it to the comic. I wanted to digest the film, see what I liked and disliked about it, and then compare it to the comic. Sure a few things got changed, sure some things got left out, that is always to be expected when you take a written story and convert it to film. I don’t think anything that was left out hurt the story, nor do I feel that the changes detracted from the overall story either. Spoilers ahead so be aware. My friend Randy and I talked about the ending being different than the book. It became a wide consensus between us as well as some other folks that the giant squid would have probably looked pretty stupid on a movie screen in today’s day and age. It may have worked when the story was originally written, but I don’t think it stands the test of time well enough to work. Was the chage to blaming Dr. Manhattan instead of some fictional aliens the best route, I don’t know, but it does work, it still achieves the same end result. The world unites to fight this new threat, thus removing the strain of nuclear war. Though in truth, how long do you think such a truce would really last? As for things left out, okay the Pirate story wouldn’t have really worked and would have only confused most mainstream audiences. I agree with some others though that if you take out the newstand parts you can’t throw it back in at the end. The way they make it seem like the paper is going to publish Rorschach’s journal bugged me a lot, it gets thrown away, so even in death Rorschach still fails at what he wanted to accomplish.
Let’s talk about casting. I have no complaints with anyone. However, Jackie Earle Haley is a little slice of brilliance. He steals the show and he pulls off the gravelly voiced vigilante so much better than Christian Bale does. Haley was Rorschach. I loved every moment he was on screen. Billy Crudup, Carla Gugino, Matthew Goode, they were all fine in their roles. I did like Jeffrey dean Morgan as the Comedian though, he seemed to fit quite well with the role.
I think the opening credits sequence is just about the coolest opening I have ever seen in a film. The style was amazing, and it accomplished a lot with conveying much of the backstory. Visually this was a fantastic movie. I could see a lot of the same style from “300″. I thought the fight scenes were great, brutal, and bloody. I am not going to rant like some people about the aparent abundance of blue penis, get over it people, it doesn’t ruin the movie and it won’t turn you gay. The direction was done superbly, the look of everything, from the customing, to the city itself, all done wonderfully.
I have heard some complaints too about some scenes that made the movie hard for some to watch, the rape scene, the little girl’s leg, the killing of the dogs. That last one I find amazing, people that can watch Rorschach kill other people but as soon as he kills a dog it goes too far. Another complaint for some is the music. It didn’t really bother me all that much. Even looking back I can’t remember when the choice of music made me cringe or evenn think that it was out of place, well, except for the end credits which have to be the loudest credits ever.
I really want to see this movie one more time before I go back and read the comic. I think a second viewing will help me solidify some of my opinions, maybe change some too. I will pay closer attention to the music and see if it throws things off for me as it did some others. I went into this movie with high hopes but low expectations. My hopes were not only met, but exceeded, so far one of the best comic adaptations I have seen, 4 1/2 Axes.